Ticket #82 (closed clarification: fixed)

Opened 6 years ago

Last modified 5 years ago

What would the DOI resolver return?

Reported by: amit Assigned to: amit
Priority: high Milestone:
Component: topaz Version:
Keywords: DOI resolver Cc:
Blocking: Blocked By:

Description

Early on in our discussions, we made the decision that every object stored within the Topaz repository will be marked with a DOI. The problem now is that it is not clear what the DOI resolver should return associated with a DOI. For example, if a user tries to retrieve the annotation via its DOI, we can return just the annotation or try and create the article context out of it.

We can handle this as long as the different "types" of objects being stored in the repository are very limited. But in the long run, do we need to associate an application with the object too to resolve the context?

Of course, simplest and probably the easiest way out is that the DOI returns the object and not the context around it. If folks want the context, then it should be created within the application context and not the DOI. This is what makes the most sense, but we should discuss it further.

Dependency Graph

Change History

07/13/06 15:54:47 changed by ronald

But why do all DOI's have to be resolvable? Just because we decide to use DOI's doesn't mean we have to register them all. Indeed, I was assuming we'd just register the articles; everything else is "internal", i.e. can't be generically resolved.

What does the handle system support? Is it just a DOI->URL mapping? Or is there more?

07/13/06 18:04:53 changed by amit

  • milestone set to TBD.

07/20/06 13:28:14 changed by amit

Think of this another way, if I want to send you an interesting annotation on an article, what do I send?

07/25/06 16:48:10 changed by amit

  • status changed from new to closed.
  • resolution set to fixed.

Long discussion with Chris and Rich on this and the general agreement is that DOI should return the object and *nothing* else. If the application requesting the object wants to build the rest of the context, they will have to do that through retrieved pieces. Besides, Topaz will never know the context completely...

07/25/06 18:05:19 changed by ronald

Agreed. Basically a normal end-user never sees the DOI - what they will send to a friend is some front-end (PlosONE) URL that gives a pretty formatted view.

08/07/07 16:25:51 changed by

  • milestone deleted.

Milestone Bugs deleted